Thursday, September 9, 2010

Week 2: Strong vs. Valid

Discuss Strong versus Valid Arguments in detail. Give an example of each from everyday life.

There is a very thin line between what a strong argument is vs. what a valid argument is. The subtle difference is recognized when you really analyzed them both. A strong argument consists of good supporting sources that make or set a point across clearly, but it does not necessarily have to be true. A valid argument, however, is just that; Valid. A valid argument is set to be based on true facts and is something that cannot be proven wrong. I guess its safe to say that what a strong argument may be, is an argument based on opinion in comparison to a valid argument. A valid argument can be strong but a valid argument can also be weak.
An example of a strong argument can be " I hate parking at the student garage, no one should park there because they always find a way to give you a $40 parking ticket for little reasons insignificant reasons that ppl don't really mean to do" this is strong argument because the person might have had an experience with parking fines, however that does not mean that the argument is necessarily true. To make this statement true you would probably use as follows " I hate parking at the student garage, no one should park there because they always find a way to give you a $40 parking ticket for little reasons insignificant reasons such as being parked a bit over the white line even though it was the ONLY way you could fit since the car right next to me parked all wrong" this is a valid argument because the ticket may be present and the car next to them may also be present to verify that what is said is true.

(does this example make sence? im just upset with the parking fines -___- room to vent.)

2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your post on strong versus valid arguments was interesting. Your arguments on parking fines were argumentative. Your arguments on getting a ticket for being parked too close to a car and be over the line caught my attention. People may had a bad experience with parking services but it does not mean the argument is true. I agree that in order for you argument to be valid is if you specifically state your premises and conclusion. Your valid argument sounds convincing for others to believe it is true. However, strong arguments do not necessarily have to be true as long as they are strong. Your strong argument was convincing. Good job on this discussion question!

    ReplyDelete